Advertisement
Coverage of what is truly interesting in the film world
RSS Feeds:All posts by this author|All comments for this post

Michael Moore Vs. CNN, Sanjay Gupta, Iraq, Mainstream Media…

Karina Longworth
By Karina Longworth posted 1 year ago
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Ma.gnolia
  • YahooMyWeb
  • StumbleUpon

Everyone’s talking this morning about this crazy segment on CNN last night. Wolf Blitzer ran a pre-recorded segment, produced by their medical correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta, questioning some of the facts about international health care in Sicko. Michael Moore then went on a ten-minute rant, accusing CNN of treating him unfairly, producing biased reporting to please their sponsors, and lying to the American people.

Gupta isn’t exactly saying that Sicko is a ball of lies; he’s mostly focused on the facts the film fails to reveal. The basic crux of his argument is this: “It’s true, the United States is the only country in the Western world without free, universal access to health care. But, you won’t find medical utopia elsewhere.” Gupta even closes his segment with something resembling an olive branch: “No matter how much Moore fudged the facts–and he did fudge some facts–there’s one everyone agrees on: the system here should be far better.”

This just seems like common sense to me–as in, anyone with a brain who watches Sicko understands that there is a give-and-take in other countries, a not-so-swell side of universal health care that Moore declines to show in order to bolster his argument.

But Moore, apparently on a mission to become a parody of himself, is no longer willing to accept even a shred of criticism. When in doubt, he always pulls the “poor little Mike versus the big bad mainstream media companies” card. He criticizes CNN for running pharmaceutical ads, but as Blitzer points out, you don’t see him demanding that Harvey Weinstein pull all Sicko ads from CNN.

The clip embedded above closes with Lou Dobbs laughing off Moore as “more of a left-wing promoter than Hugo Chavez”, but oddly, Moore actually spends the majority of his CNN screen time deflecting attention away from his film. I guess he figures there’s more long-term value in turning the appearance into a stunt, demanding that Blitzer and CNN “apologize to the American people” for their failure to ask the proper questions about the war in Iraq, and even slamming Gupta in particular for embedding with the troops and not coming back with a scathing report (according to Blitzer, Gupta was too busy performing neurosurgery on injured soldiers to do much negative reporting).

Moore has a point-by-point rebuttal of Gupta’s piece posted on his own site. It’s not exactly a gleeful “smackdown”–the general tone is, “Gupta’s truth is sort of true, but it’s not the whole truth.” Nonetheless, he’s still demanding an apology from CNN, and, according to BoingBoing, asking that his fans do the same.

UPDATE: According to FishbowlNY, Michael Moore will be back on CNN tonight, “debating” Sanjay Gupta face-to-face. Fishbowl also confirms that I’m not crazy, and that Moore did seem to put a very strange spin on his enunciation of Gupta’s last name–they refer to it as “the Kwik-E-Mart pronunciation.”

Add your comments