My post on Huey Lewis’ two, questionably classic contributions to the Back to the Future soundtrack garnered some impassioned responses. Ryan Stewart wrote in to defend the track that I called the lesser of the two, Back in Time:
Cassette? Um, I own the LP. Back in Time is the best example ever of a plot-song. It’s that 1/1,000 that actually work, and work really awesomely, and the kind of thing they’d never have the guts to do these days.
Oh yeah? Well, never underestimated the guts of David Gordon Green. A friend of Spout pointed me to this Stereogum item from Monday, in which Seth Rogen, writer and star of Gordon Green’s Summer 2008 comedy The Pineapple Express, confirms that none other than Huey Lewis was commissioned to write “a track reminiscent of Power Of Love” for the movie. My source says he’s heard the song, and he confirms that it incorporates “lyrics that tell the plot of the movie, with ‘Pineapple Express’ in the chorus.”
So is the plot song ready for its comeback? Are YOU ready for the plot song’s comeback? Can you even name the last film that featured a full-on plot song? I can’t. While you’re pondering all of that, watch the above clip from The Pineapple Express. I’ve heard one or two whispers that the film could very well show up at Harry Knowles’ Butt-Numb-A-Thon this weekend (which, sadly, I’m not going to be able to attend), so we might get a full review of Huey’s contribution sooner rather than later.
My friends and I have been talking about this very thing the last couple of months. I, for one, am ready for the resurgence of the unironic plot song. However, I think most people will see it as another of the film’s jokes (I mean, it’s Huey Lewis, right?) , if they even appreciate it at all. What would be truly gutsy and a logical extension of this great film tradition would be to use a musician with considerable “indie” cache to create a true throwback plot song that doesn’t include the requisite wink and a nod to safely place it in the “yeah, we know, but isn’t it funny” zone. But is that even possible anymore? There was a certain incongruous innocence that permeated that era that I don’t think exists today. In fact, I happened to watch “The Running Man” last night and got into quite an interesting discussion with friends about how a potential remake would be doomed from the start (remember “Rollerball”?) because the original was so firmly lodged in that era’s cultural moment (while also being quite ahead of its time). I think this may also serve as an apt analogy for the potential resurgence of the plot song. It’s so entrenched in that period that our generation will view it as an ironic joke while people of younger generations will simply assess it on its merits as a song. So unless Huey Lewis writes one amazing song about the Pineapple Express, the resurgence of the plot song may be doomed to failure. On the other hand, if Kenny Loggins…
I just saw Huey Lewis in concert and they played they the new Pineapple Express song. After hearing it, I can confidently say they’ve got a MONSTER HIT on their hands. Extremely catchy and very 80s. It will certainly get a positive reaction.