If you were even slightly irritated by Ellen Page’s too-precocious performance in Juno, then you might want to avoid the trailer for Noam Murro’s Smart People. In the movie, which screened at Sundance last week, Page plays yet another teen who seems too smart for her own good. In fact, it is obvious that the trailer is trying to make this character appear similar to her Oscar-nominated role. Now, I’m not one of the many Juno haters, and I think Page has talent, but doesn’t it take away from her performance in Juno to show us that she’s doing the exact same thing in her follow-up? Never mind the fact that Smart People seems like The Squid and the Whale meets The Ballad of Jack and Rose — I’ve heard that it is pretty funny and smart despite its familiar territories — I’m more turned off by the fact that it’s like Juno II without our favorite Juno I actors (Cera, Bateman and Simmons, of course).

Not that you can go wrong with Thomas Haden Church, with or without a catfish mustache (I just watched Spider-Man 3 for the first time, and he’s the only good thing about it). Here he plays the adopted brother of a pompous Carnegie Mellon professor played by Dennis Quaid. Page plays Quaid’s Young Republican daughter; Ashton Holmes (A History of Violence) plays his son; and Sarah Jessica Parker is his former student-turned-doctor who becomes his love interest. Apparently Church’s character is more free spirited than the rest, and he probably teaches them all to have more fun in life. This sounds pretty unoriginal, but from what I’ve read the film as a whole works as a satire of academia and specialized knowledge. Of course, that doesn’t mean we’re going to enjoy any of those too-intelligent characters while waiting for them to relax.

Considering I think of Page as being the new Winona Ryder (though Hard Candy and Juno are combined to be her Heathers, and still she’s not quite as good), this is either her Mermaids or her Great Balls of Fire! (the latter only because of Quaid) and in a few years she’ll be wearing period dress for directors like Coppola and Scorsese. But even if she’s able to similarly break out of her precocious high schooler shtick, she could easily end up like Ryder and one day be uncomfortably trying to fit into normal adult roles. But she will similarly have lost what we originally fell for about her. I have a sinking suspicion that we’re going to be thinking of Juno MacGuff every time we watch Page from here on out.

Smart People will be distributed by Miramax on April 11, 2008.