I am one of the biggest supporters of digital 3D, but I just can’t get behind Journey to the Center of the Earth 3D. It appears to be the most exploitive of the technology as little more than a gimmick and attraction. Every bit of computer generated imagery looks tailor made to look neat in three-dimensions. And then the story was probably constructed around those shots. Hell, even that non-CGI shot of Brendan Fraser spitting into the sink seems to exist only so that the spit will appear to fly at you. This isn’t a movie; it’s an amusement park-appropriate spectacle — like Captain EO.
Directed by Oscar-winning ILM effects master Eric Brevig (Total Recall) and based on the classic Jules Verne story, Journey to the Center of the Earth 3D is obviously about a journey to the center of the earth, in 3D. It also apparently features dinosaurs, phosphorescent hummingbirds, giant man-eating fly-trap-type plants and a really, really long fall that reminds me of Fraser’s role in the underrated Joe Dante comedy Looney Tunes: Back in Action. Those things alone at least make the movie sound better than The Core. Of course, that isn’t saying much.
The thing is, with so much green-screen and computer imagery, New Line might as well have just made this an animated film. It’s not as if this is actually the first live-action digital 3D movie, despite the trailer’s claim. No, it was beaten to that punch by both U2 3D and the Hannah Montana/Miley Cyrus concert film by as much as four months. Maybe it is at least the first live-action digital 3D narrative movie, but considering the narrative may actually have taken a back seat to the visuals, that might not be a worthy claim, either.
As far as I know, Journey to the Center of the Earth 3D hits all kinds of screens (not just 3D-equipped screens, which makes for an awkward title) on July 11.
I hadn’t even noticed, but of course Brevig also worked on Captain EO. Thanks to Jessica at Cinematical for pointing that out.
But sometimes you need something that’s strictly exploitative of technology to get people to accept or even desire it. I’d never go out of my way to watch something in 3D, but I’m going to see this one. Mostly because of Brendan Fraser, but that might make me a convert to 3D. It’s all good.
The 3D looked very impressive in the trailer, we will find out exactly what live action 3D can do when this comes out. Not holding out much hope for a great film though.