It’s not definite yet, but it looks like Oscar-nominated actor/director Kenneth Branagh will be taking the helm of Marvel Studios’ comic book adaptation Thor. Most young moviegoers know Branagh as Gilderoy Lockhart (from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets), but he’s otherwise better known for primarily directing films of Shakespeare’s works. He also tends to cast mostly trained Shakespearean actors, although he has been known to include an Alicia Silverstone or a Matthew Lillard in his ensembles. Additionally, he’s been known for odd casting choices, such as Robert De Niro for the Monster in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein.
Who will he cast this time in the Asgardian ensemble that will make up the film? It might not actually be totally up to him, but if it is, it might look a little like this:
Kenneth Branagh as Thor/Donald Blake
I know what you’re thinking. He’s old. But he’s only five years older than Iron Man’s Robert Downey Jr. and only 3 years older than Brad Pitt, who recently was rumored to be at the top of Marvel’s wish list for the role. Anyway, he’s cast himself as Hamlet, Dr. Frankenstein and Henry V. So, it would be fitting if he cast himself in the lead here, too. The only issue, of course, is that the script now apparently features Thor’s alter ego, Donald Blake, and he’s reportedly written as a med student, not a full-on doctor. Oh, and for Thor, Branagh will have to beef up tremendously. Or not. If he actually got away with playing the character, he could probably also get away with not giving in to the whole height and muscle problem.
Keanu Reeves as Loki
Branagh previously cast Reeves in the Shakespeare adaptation Much Ado About Nothing, and after more than 15 years, it’s time for them to work together again. Plus, Reeves is fully capable of being a nasty trickster and he should certainly be taking on more villain roles.
Ian Holm as Odin
Now that Branagh is linked to the film, past rumors that Brian Blessed already was cast as Odin make more sense. And Blessed is actually who will likely get the part, especially if Marvel is paying attention to the movie blogs and message boards today. But maybe he could cast Holm, who also acted in Branagh’s Frankenstein and Henry V. Sure, he’s way too short, and he doesn’t have that monstrous voice that Blessed has. But doesn’t he just have a more fatherly look to him?
Brian Blessed as Volstagg
With Holm as Odin, Blessed will then have to take on the part of this member of the Warriors Three. He may not be fat enough, but he’s loud enough. Another great choice would be Branagh’s co-star from Harry Potter, Robbie Coltrane. Why? Because he also played Falstaff in Branagh’s Henry V, and according to Wikipedia, Stan Lee likely based Volstagg on that Shakespeare character.
Jude Law as Fandral
This other member of the Warriors Three should be played by someone along the lines of Errol Flynn, who clearly was Stan Kirby’s model for the character. And Law, who recently starred in Branagh’s Sleuth, portrayed Flynn in Scorsese’s The Aviator. He may be too big a movie star for the supporting part, but Law should probably be demoted a bit, anyway.
Kevin Kline as Hogun
Rounding out the Warriors Three is this long-mustached fellow, and Kline, who appears in Branagh’s As You Like It, is always great with mustached characters (think The Pirates of Penzance and A Fish Called Wanda). Kline needs to be in a superhero movie, anyway, badly. 20 years ago, he would have been a perfect choice for a character like Tony Stark, but now he is due for at least a supporting role.
Gemma Arterton as Sif
She’s about to break out big time with the latest 007 film, Quantum of Solace, and Guy Ritchie’s RocknRolla, which will put her in a perfect position to show off her Shakespearean talents and her other assets as Thor’s Asgardian lover.
Emily Mortimer as Jane Foster
If indeed the Earthly side of Thor is shown in Branagh’s film, his nurse and temporary girlfriend should also make an appearance. The best pick is Mortimer, who previously worked with the director on Love’s Labour’s Lost. Unfortunately, the character’s more likely to be played by a younger actress, some flavor of the month, a la Arterton.
Robert De Niro as Absorbing Man
The reported villains in Thor are Loki, Karnilla, Malekith and Thrym, but I’ll keep wishing for an appearance from former boxer Carl “Crusher” Creel. Not only is he a cool villain with cool powers, but he’d make for some cool special effects. Give him a cameo at least? And in the part cast De Niro, who could make up for his role as the Monster in Frankenstein. Surely I’m not the only person who’d like to see Bobby D shave his head and swing a wrecking ball around.
If you’re concerned about Branagh beefing up, take another look at Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. I seem to remember he spent about half that movie stripped to the waist and looking pretty buff. Of course, how many years ago was that?
Alright if they do not lock down Brian Blessed as Volstagg we need an underground movement for Brad Lyon from All’s Faire In Love. The guy fits the perfect bill for the character, Big Chest, legs the size of a house and a voice to match. He is heavy in the part of the Football Coach in All’s Faire In Love so he has the weight to pull it off. Besides, as a former world bronze medalist in wrestling and a football player the guy can carry the feel of an imposing character pretty well.
If not Volstagg, if they go with Absorbing Man there isn’t a better guy to swing a wrecking ball!
(If you don’t know Lyon, think Jack Black on steroids).
After watching HBO’s TrueBlood series, I think the Swedish actor Alexander Skarsgard should be cast as Thor. I’ve seen pictures of other roles he’s played and he had short hair and glasses totally pulling off the ‘doctor’ look which could solve the “hiring of two actors’ issue that they want to avoid.
I know they were trying to avoid having 2 actors play Blake/Thor so after watching the show TrueBlood on HBO I stumbled across the Swedish actor Alexander Skarsgard. I looked him up online and saw pictures of him indicating he can totally pull of Dr. Donald Blake and on TrueBlood, he is buff and blonde for Thor! What’s great about him is he’s a relative unknown and it might be better for the franchise (not to mention his future in Hollywood).
Marvel wants to hire someone who can actually act to play Thor. Even if whoever is cast in the role isn’t the right size, I’m sure they could doctor him up with some special effects to achieve the right look.
Branagh directing Thor = good. If you ever read the original Kirby/ Lee Tales of Asgard you know. Especially since Marvel Studios will make him ramp up the action, considering he’s never done it before.
Branagh AS Thor = one of the most inane if not just wrong things I’ve ever heard. He IS too old to play Thor. Odin, maybe. Thor, no. They need an unknown or little known actor who can act well and resemble the part. Save the big stars for the supporting roles.
And please Marvel, spare us the ZZ Top Thor with a beard. No King Thor or Thor from the Ultimates. Just give us our good ole classic hammer weilding Thunder God.
I think Alexander Skarsgard would be an excellent choice for Thor. He has the look. His voice is educated and he could pull down the merchanise machine with his left elbow. He can really act without little effort. As for the other selections, well , they suck. What is Marvel Comics thinking. Branagh can direct but he should have done Thor as himself when he was pussyfooting around with Frankenstein. As for the other actors, look up a little movie called “Thirteen warrior” with Antonio Banderas. Those actors could pull off a band of vikings and they can act as well. I would rather see a movie that was believeable than another marvel comic remake that makes me want to throw down my comics. Also find a real scandanavian woman that can act. I do not want to hear another screwed up accent and not someone who has studied Rosetta Stone.
For Fandral pick Cary Elwes. He can play serious like in “Kiss the Girls”.
And I get sick and tired of seeing these old men actors with young girls. It’s like watching an old man perv on some high school girl. Yuck. Do like the X-Men as least put everyone near the same age range.
Try Ryan Reynolds as Loki. Have you seen his body and he can pull off mean mischievous. Who is casting this movie? They obviously haven’t put a lot of thought into it. No one is going to take Keanu Reaves as a nordic person. Its so obvious what his physical heritage let alone he’s Nemo dodging bullets! Brian Blessed? Isn’t he in a wheel chair from playing the king of the birds from that old Flash Gordan movie? I hope they have medical because some of these actors could throw out a hip or bust a knee. Make sure they all have that safety device that calls the cops when they fall down!