It finally happened: my obsession with MSNBC has dovetailed with legitimate movie news! Sort of!
Tonight the New York Times broke the news that over a year ago, Dan Mirvish (filmmaker and co-founder of the Slamdance Film Festival) and Eitan Gorlin (whose directorial debut, The Holy Land, won the Grand Jury Prize at that festival and was nominated for an Independent Spirit Award) made up a fake adviser to John McCain named Martin Eisenstadt. On Monday, MSNBC’s David Schuster reported on air that Martin Eisenstadt had taken credit for the “Palin thinks Africa is a country” leak. Eisenstadt had indeed published a post on his blog (tagline: “Because freedom isn’t free”) claiming to be the leaker, which no one at MSNBC bothered to look into deeply before Schuster’s report, otherwise they might have discovered that Eisenstadt a) is a made up person, and b) didn’t actually talk to Carl Cameron, the Fox news reporter who broke the “anonymous sources say Palin doesn’t know Africa is a continent” story.
MSNBC weren’t the only ones snowed – The Huffington Post, The National Review and The Los Angeles Times have all previously used Eisenstadt’s made-up blog full of made-up insider information as a source. TV Newser started digging into the story yesterday; they posted an email “from” “Eisenstadt” which, in retrospect, probably should have tipped all of us off. “It’s strange for me (and all a bit Hegelian) to get requests to prove that I exist,” writes “Martin,” before insisting that “every single blog that says I am a ‘hoax’ has emanated from a single, bitter individual who for some reason has a vendetta against me - a golf blogger allegedly named ‘Wolfrum.’” William K. Wolfrum’s blog looks so overtly hoaxy that it might actually be not a hoax … except that at the end of the Times story,”Wolfrum” himself seems to imply that he doesn’t actually exist. I think.
In any case, above you can watch the first part of a fake BBC documentary Mirvish and Gorlin produced about Eisenstadt, called The Last Republican. Gorlin plays the, uh, titular lead, and he does a superb job of saying things like, “We can bomb every rainforest back into prehistory, but we’ve got to have some kind of economic model that people can embrace,” and “Bill Kristol was my counselor in Zionist summer camp”, with a straight face.
Karina, talkin’ about gettin’ the dirt on world leaders, from YouTube - check this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7iQRFP_e90
Wow, you’re fast.
this is brilliant. a media FAIL. and a great hoax. i almost feel bad for Palin.
I would imagine it would require hours and hours of research to find out if this “Wolfrum” character is real or not.
I can assure you that William K. Wolfrum and his golf blog are quite real. I used to edit at the golf web site for which he blogs. He’s a nice guy, pretty funny, but I was unaware of his activities as a media critic. You go, Bill!
[...] And, yes, I exist. I do dabble in satire, but I’m not a hoax. Seriously, people, you’re killing [...]
I am married to the blogger allegedly named “Wolfrum” and sometimes I also think he does not exist. Especially when I ask him to fix something around the house or to do groceries. It´s like talking to someone that is not there.
[...] expands upon a story originally reported by The New York Times on the mysterious case of Martin Eisenstadt, a [...]
[...] 2. One of the reasons for that could be this - Perez-Pena ended it with a tongue-in-cheek suggestion that I was part of the hoax. The final quote of the story doesn’t come from me - when he asked me how he could trust I was real, I laughed and said that I was pretty easy to check out, having worked for daily newspapers before. In fact, it turns out that Perez-Pena and I are from the same area of Southern California. Nonetheless, several folks in the blogosphere have questioned whether I am real or if I was part of the hoax. [...]
Slamdance is Awful - The films that come out of this sh!thole are worthless and unwatchable- not even worth putting on 3am public access TV.
Ha ha! Martin Eisenstadt pwned the news media! A simple Google search would have shown that the Harding Institute for Freedom and Democracy is fake. Everyone knows that the dinosaur news media will never change. This isn’t the first hoax that the news media fell for and this won’t be the last hoax. The dinosaur news media is just going to keep getting pwned by people like Martin until no one can trust their reporting anymore and they go extinct.
i’m still confused about this.
if the original report was based on a hoax, why did sarah palin essentially admit that there was a problem with her ability to distinguish africa as a continent?
[...] Jen, Random Babble, Rotus, SpoutBlog, Bastard Logic, Ravenwolf68, Sprawled Out, The Church of the Apocalyptic Kiwi, Portly Dyke, [...]