Movie news on your iPhone today!
Advertisement
Coverage of what is truly interesting in the film world

TOP STORY:

RSS Feeds:All posts by this author|All comments for this post

Isn’t There Anything Good About Terminator Salvation? Today in Film Bloggery 05/21/09

Christopher Campbell
By Christopher Campbell posted 5 months ago
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Ma.gnolia
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon

I’ll come right out and admit that I enjoyed Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines. Do I think it was a great action flick, on par with the previous two installments in the franchise? Not at all, but there was enough good stuff in the sequel to entertain me. And I know I’m not alone in this opinion. Unfortunately, it doesn’t appear there’s much that’s good in Terminator Salvation, reviews for which are downright terrible. This deeply upsets me, because this was the blockbuster I looked forward to most this summer. Now I don’t feel there’s any reason to check it out.

Of course, I’m probably alone in that last statement. Wednesday night’s midnight shows were a hit and the movie is expected to be huge at the box office this weekend (the fact that it opened on a Thursday before Memorial Day should pad the gross very well). So, since many of you will be going to see this anyway, and hardly pay attention to scores at Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, I might as well reach around the blogosphere and pull out as many favorable quotes as I can find, even those buried inside primarily negative reviews. And hopefully you will do me the favor of commenting with any other good stuff that makes it worth it for me to buy a ticket.

Thanks in advance for that, and here’s the positive spin, after the jump:

  • Alex Billington at First Showing is 100% positive in his judgment:

    believe it or not, I actually loved Terminator Salvation. I went into it expecting to hate it but walked out loving it, through and through. I really think McG pulled it off. It looks great, sounds great, the action is awesome, the effects are even better, the performances are all great, what more do we need besides that? Oh right, a good story, and you know what, it had one. Sure it had a few rough edges and some minor plot holes, but overall I enjoyed it, in fact, I had a blast watching it.

  • The Arrow at JoBlo is just as excited about the movie as Alex, if not more so. From his “bottom line” summation:

    Good story, strong actors, fly visuals and jaw dropping visual effects, I doubt I’ll have more fun with a film this summer than I had with this puppy. Shoddy character/relationship development and a handful of severe plot holes aside; this was one served up TIME WELL SPENT in spades. It’s a 3 on 4 on paper rating wise for me, but I’m giving it a 3 and a half because it thrilled me so damn much!

  • Erik Davis at Cinematical opens his review raving positively:

    Terminator Salvation roars to life on screen with enough gutsy firepower to literally shake you in your seat. She’s a mean, loud metallic beast that hasn’t eaten in years, and the only commands she understands come in the form of growls, snarls, bullets and explosions. You can’t really ask for more from an action picture (well you can, but we’ll get to that); with Terminator Salvation, director McG proves that he’s more than a punchline for online jokes — his action scenes are fierce and eye-popping; he gives us the post-apocalyptic Skynet world we’ve always wanted to see and then asks if we want seconds or thirds.

  • Massawyrm at Aint it Cool New may have the most excited reaction of all:

    I LOVE LOVE LOVE the action here. McG does a great job of putting you in the middle of some crazy, awesome battles against the machines. From gritty urban warfare against stray terminators to dogfights against Hunter-Killer airships, this thing hits a number of extremes and puts us in a world entirely destroyed by the machines. This is a post-apocalyptic film, a nuclear waste nightmare in which the last few humans alive work together in a loosely organized network to try and bring down the machines. There are some very cool sequences and not a boring moment to be found throughout the breathless film.

  • Keith Phipps at the A.V. Club favors the movie over its predecessor:

    As long as McG keeps the action moving, the film remains on solid ground, matching and often surpassing the thoroughly adequate 2003 entry Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines. He’s clearly immersed himself in the work of Terminator mastermind James Cameron, and Cameron’s relentless approach to action—juiced up by some state-of-2009 digital effects—serves him well.

  • A.O. Scott at The New York Times favors the movie over some of its summer blockbuster peers:

    [The movie] has a brute integrity lacking in some of the other seasonal franchise movies. It parades neither the egghead aspirations of “Star Trek” nor the thick-skulled pretensions of “X-Men Origins: Wolverine,” but instead feels both comfortable with its limitations and justly proud of its accomplishments.

  • Charlie Jane Anders at i09 thinks it’s at least better than X-Men Origins: Wolverine and has “more real-feeling” action sequences than Transformers. She also claims, “there’s a good, maybe even great, movie here, and you catch glimpses of it from time to time.” Here’s her description of one of those times:

    there are a couple of real stand-out action sequences early on, and some fun stuff later on. In fact, the action sequences are pleasingly free of jump-cuts. You have one sequence, where John Connor climbs out of an underground base just as it blows up, then he gets in a helicopter, and the helicopter gets smashed, and he crashes it upside down, which is all one continous take. And it’s a really nice-looking sequence.

  • Capone at Aint it Cool News also highlights this “damned impressive” scene and calls TS “a hell of a war film.” More praise for the action:

    Most of the action sequences are top notch, from an attack at a gas station where we see the full range of Terminator variations (I really like the ones that look like motorcycles) to the climactic battle set at a Terminator production facility. Since so much of the film revolves around some powerful, well-staged action set pieces, if that’s all you care about, you should have a pretty great time watching this movie.

  • Quint at Aint it Cool News commends one of the performances:

    out of everybody in the movie Anton Yelchin knocks it out of the park. I never in a million years would have thought that his performance would be my favorite in this film, but the kid takes enough of Michael Biehn’s mannerisms (a lot of talking through his teeth) to make Kyle feel like the one we know without mimicking Biehn’s performance.

  • Christopher Monfette at IGN thinks the movie is unnecessary, but that doesn’t mean it’s not worth seeing:

    just because something is ultimately unnecessary doesn’t mean it can’t be entertaining, and so long as you don’t require Terminator Salvation to live up to its cinematic pedigree, you’ll likely find a visually impressive and effects-filled way to pass two hours away from the mid-summer heat. Ask anything greater, and you’re more likely to discover damnation than Salvation.

Add your comments

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.

  • Anonymous Coward said

    I saw it Thursday and loved it. You almost cannot disappoint with any Terminator movie as long as you have action, good acting, and great effects … this movie had all three. I am HUGE Terminator fan and this movie did not disappoint; I am looking forward to the next installment.

  • Noah Haviland said

    Terminator Salvation is an awesome action flick.

    I totally enjoyed this movie.

    What is a Terminator movie? I refer to the original to answer that question:

    A Terminator movie is a sci-fi action movie which humanity fights machines. Lots of things gets blown up, there are chase sequences, and there is a thin plot line involving saving humanity, saving the future, and saving John Connor.

    Now does Terminator Salvation deliver those things?

    You bet your ass it does.

    Do I need cheesy humor that T2 and T3 had? Hell no.

    If you don’t like action films with a hint of sci-fi, then why have you bothered to watch any of the Terminator films?

    Thats like expecting a Rambo movie to be something it isn’t.

  • TLB said

    I for one would love to see at least one more Terminator movie and see John Connor bring Skynet down. People can call it “unnecessary” all they want but this was a good movie. Great action, good effects and the acting was up to par. Critics never were any fun.

  • the Unexpressed Advantage » I Told You There Were Bubbles said

    [...] Does Anti-Virus Software Matter? Should I tell my boss I found nude photos of his daughter? Is Terminator Salvation Any Good? Will I love this Movie? Ahh. The weekend cometh. I’m just happy that I don’t have to drive a [...]

  • Anne Harbaugh said

    A great story and excellent acting. I have decided the critics must
    have seen another movie because I found myself immersed in a world that I would never want to exist in. I give high marks to McG to believing
    this is the world that Cormac McCarthy described in THE ROAD.
    Christian Bale did an amazing job as John Conner. His portrayal as an
    individual who is tired of the war and starting to doubt if he is the person he has been raised to be is perfect.
    Sam Worthington was excellent as Marcus Wright. An individual who is truly immersed with parts that he was not born with.
    Anton Yelchin as Kyle Reese was believable as the teen who sets out to find Conner.
    Too bad critics did not see the same movie I saw.

    Anne Harbaugh

  • Timoteo said

    Terminator Salvation blows Star Trek out of the water! It is a work of immense creative genius. Reviewing films is the most subjective thing on the planet–I’m surprised everybody doesn’t know that. What anyone says about ANY film is just ONE person’s take. I would never avoid a movie just because of that..some of my favorite films of all time were roundly badmouthed!

  • Random dude said

    This movie granted, could have had more story. It had more action (which the action sequences were very well done)than story. Could have shown more character development such as between Connor and Reese. It was well established in the first one that Connor and Reese seemed to have a special relationship that you later know that Reese is John’s father and John himself knows this in the future. Aside from that McG actually covered some good little facts. Example, in T2 its made clear that Connor in the future had this big scar on his face which he didn’t get as a kid(T2), didn’t have when he was a young adult(T3), but got it when he was older, which they show how he get’s it. They also got a lot of the machines from the first two pretty similar(Ground HK’s,Aerial HK’s, and his very accurate description of that T-600! Bulky mofo, thought that was the most bad ass till the T-800 came out!). Another great thing about the film! The introduction to the T-800 model terminator was awesome. In the other movies the t-800’s seemed so mechanical(even t-3 they seemed that way) but when they had skin they moved like normal people. In this movie they move exactly the same, flesh or metal. In matter of fact they were more scary with just the metal. The list goes on but if your a fan and know the background you’ll enjoy it. I’m a geek, I know haha. Enjoy though