Movie news on your iPhone today!
Advertisement
Coverage of what is truly interesting in the film world

TOP STORY:

RSS Feeds:All posts by this author|All comments for this post

2 Troubling Things Regarding PAPER HEART

Karina Longworth
By Karina Longworth posted 3 months ago
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Ma.gnolia
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon

Paper Heart comes out this week, and I am not going to republish my review from Sundance, mostly because I’ve seen the film again since then and actually think I was way too forgiving the first time around. But there are two things about the film that I think are worth noting:

1) Michael Cera was billed long before Paper Heart’s Sundance premiere as Charlene Yi’s “real-life boyfriend,” and the blurriness between the film’s scripted and documentary elements have been the major hook for much of the ample press coverage that Heart has enjoyed. And yet, in an interview with IFC.com, Charlene Yi now claims that she and Cera “never dated.” The little indie movie “packaged by” a major talent agency had a cynical marketing gimmick all along? I’ll never trust an anonymously sourced Hollywood Reporter story pregaming Sundance again!

2) On my second viewing of Paper Heart, a soundbite from one of the ostensible documentary sections of the film stood out in a way it couldn’t have at the Sundance screening. Yi goes to an Atlanta playground and talks about love with a group of black kids, and at one point a girl who looks to be pre-teen gushes, “Us girls love Chris Brown.” A relatively harmless admission of a celebrity crush in January, but totally creepy seven months later in light of the knowledge that Brown not only beat up his ex-girlfriend Rihanna but over the following months seemed to have significant trouble showing remorse for it.

The clip has adds nothing to the movie narratively — on the contrary, it’s unsettling enough to momentarily stop the film dead in its tracks, especially in light of the chatter that young girls don’t think domestic violence is that big of a deal. So why wasn’t it edited out in the six months between the Rihanna assault and the film’s release?

Add your comments

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.

  • Dignan said

    I don’t want to say anything that will get me sued but I *suspect* the whole “we never dated” angle is either revisionist history or another supposedly hilarious piece of performance art by Yi. Long before the hype machine for the film began around Sundance, Cera and Yi have been regarded as a couple. As far back as 2007 I was having conversations along the line of “you know Michael Cera is dating that weird stoner chick from Knocked Up?” The latest story (direct from Charlene’s mouth), that she used to babysit Cera when they were both younger and they just decided to submit the “script” to him through proper channels rings especially hollow.

    Also, yes the Chris Brown line should have gone since it’s clearly not that type of comedy.

  • Pierre said

    Come to think of it, despite hearing all the talk of them being a couple from gossip sites and blogs over the past few months, I don’t remember hearing it from anyone actually reputable. It could have just been a misunderstanding that arose from the “documentary” positing of the film during production.

    Charlyne also did an interview on The Sound of Young America recently where she says they’re just playing characters and that Michael’s inclusion was just down to convenience (them being friends and all). Oh and she also throws out the choice quote: “I feel like, this sounds awful but, my voice sounds like a deaf person.”

    And good for you for taking a more critical view on Paper Heart but gosh, your Sundance Review was already pretty harsh!

  • John said

    If they can’t do the advance screening correctly (i.e., they gave away too many tickets for the advance screening and some people after driving an hour to see the movie were turned away), I question the effort and professionalism that was put into the movie.